We don’t have “trust issues”; we have been shamed and betrayed. We have sound, empirical reasons not to be trusting.

Blaming victims for domestic violence: how psychology taught us to be helpless

By 

The story of how psychology framed women for their own assaults began, as so many of psychology’s stories do, with some trapped animals. In the late 1960s, psychologist Martin Seligman conducted a series of behavioural experiments with dogs. He electrically shocked them at random and observed their responses.

After being locked in cages and subjected to pain that was unpredictable and uncontrollable, the dogs eventually gave up their attempts to escape, even when their cage doors were opened. In a now classic case of reframing, Seligman coined the term “learned helplessness” to describe their responses.

This new theory was incredibly attractive. It neatly and conveniently located the problem in the victims of violence, and manipulated their reality-based perceptions of a toxic and life-threatening environment.

Learned helplessness was such a socially palatable label for repeated victimisation that it’s still regularly applied to many victims of social, institutional and interpersonal violence. This includes, most notably, women subjected to domestic violence.

Like the slippery concepts of low self-esteem, Stockholm syndrome, co-dependence or traumatic bonding, learned helplessness has entered our vernacular. It has swallowed up socially accurate explanations for violence, until nothing is left but to blame the victim.

Last year, clinical psychologist Sallee McLaren argued half the responsibility for domestic violence lies with the victim.

Journalist Julia Baird’s much-echoed critique accurately positioned Dr McLaren’s piece in the context of a long history of “provocation” theories. These attempt to explain domestic violence as a predictable response to a woman’s inability to follow the rules of appropriate communication.

Baird also rightly questioned Dr McLaren’s expertise in attributing responsibility for domestic violence.

But unfortunately for women seeking therapeutic support, in order to survive and escape domestic violence, therapists of all persuasions have been specifically trained to locate the problem in their clients. Dr McLaren is no exception in a profession that continues to focus research on the individual attributes of victims of violence, and to pitch their therapeutic techniques towards victim responsibility.

This contributes to women’s disempowerment and to our overall inability to see the violent forest for the trees.

Therapists working to support women in situations of domestic violence need to move outside of individual psychology and away from therapy. They need to name the wider problem and directly address how the social determinants of gendered violence are affecting the health and safety of the women they’re working with.

To do this requires a complete overhaul and a rejection of much of our own teaching. Therapists must relearn a feminist framework of male entitlement, power and control, and stop embracing apologist responses such as anger management.

Then, the “damaged man” who is too wounded to control himself and needs our understanding disappears. He becomes, more accurately, a man who skilfully uses violence to manage his rage and needs to be controlled.

Instead of the woman who has learned to be helpless, women’s responses to men’s violence can be understood as adaptive behaviour. This occurs within a fundamentally toxic social environment in which being subjected to violence is treated as a personal failure and where every response is either pitied or pathologised.

Such an overhaul requires therapists to engage in the painful process of facing our profession’s complicity in violence against women. Anything less is not only dangerous and ineffective, but a significant and widely debilitating contribution to the problem.

It is true that women who have experienced violence are different from other people who have not. We are different because we have been violated. We don’t have “trust issues”; we have been shamed and betrayed. We have sound, empirical reasons not to be trusting.

We don’t “keep choosing violent men”. There are simply enough of them to go around to put one woman in this country in hospital every three hours. And violence of all kinds has such a profound impact on our available resources that we become increasingly vulnerable to violence the more of it we are forced to endure.

We have not learned to be helpless; we have learned from our histories. In our psyches, in our hearts and in our minds we have been changed. How could we not be?

Like Seligman’s dogs, we have learned the inside of the cage and the outside of the cage are not always so very different after all. If therapy is going to help change our minds, hearts and responses, then it needs to help change our world.

4 thoughts on “We don’t have “trust issues”; we have been shamed and betrayed. We have sound, empirical reasons not to be trusting.

Add yours

      1. This helps me further understand what my wife went through. I think I’ve told you her story before. She says she has trust issues, but after reading this, I see it goes way deeper than that. I can use this information and knowledge to further help her… and to help modify any of my behavior or approach. Thank you so much for just being you and being a source of great information. – Hugs, Trip

        Like

  1. For me it’s the shame and humiliation that I am struggling with most. Trust is superficial- it’s what they did to betray that trust that hurts the most.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑

Self-Love~Health~Change

Be a part of the inspiration

Needull in a haystack

Selected. Sorted. Shared.

GJ Stevens

I am a Writer

Narcissistic MIL

Life with a personality disordered mother in law.

The Real Puppet Master

Insights of a marionette who cut herself loose & took back her life from a puppet master

A Jental Heart

Abuse Survivor Taking Back My Life; Advocate For Those Who Cant.

Biker, Books and Yarn

The Things I Love!

Her mission is our mission

Suicide, bullying, jes, bipolar, hope

My House In Virginia

Lessons Learned From "Love" With a Narcissist

nomusasite

~ Hello! There thank you for visiting my site . Please feel free to view more.~

Erica DeCima

Once a foster child, Always a foster child

tripx713

A new and Improved Trip!

Becoming His Tapestry

Because I am in the process of becoming, of allowing my Master to weave the various threads of my life into His Masterpiece.

VINCE POETRY FARM

SOWING SEEDS OF POETRY, EXPECTING HUGE HARVEST #POEMS

Living Broken

The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit.

WIL WHEATON dot NET

50,000 Monkeys at 50,000 Typewriters Can't Be Wrong

thelastgoodbi

It's a play on words, not a byline.

Her Patchwork Heart

A BLOG ABOUT BEING PAINFULLY HUMAN

Pink Creative Shutterbug

#SupportSurvivors

Mae Jacolo Aguilar "AppLe"

"Character is like a tree and reputation like a shadow. The shadow is what we think of it; the tree is the real thing". ABRAHAM LINCOLN

In Dianes Kitchen

Recipes showing step by step directions with pictures and gadget reviews

The Godly Chic Diaries

Smiling • Writing • Dreaming

Don't Let The Mask Fool You

This WordPress.com site is the bee's knees

SparklesonPages

"Brighten the world with your Sparkle"

InvestInYourselfFirst!!

Be A Warrior 🎯 And Get Out From The Misconceptions Of Your Life!!

ARJung

writing #MR and #FTA fairy tales with a steampunk and mythpunk twist

Holistic healing

Healing from narcissistic abuse

Overcoming Narcissistic Abuse

Healing with Gentlekindness Coaching

WRITINGS OF A STOUTHEARTED SOUL

Featuring Brave: The True Story of my life and various other tales.

Artist 9 to 5

Welcome to the home of creative arts...

Broken Justice

Our court case is over. Dealing with the aftermath of narcissistic abuse has just begun.

CynthiaBaileyRug

From The Desk Of Cynthia Bailey-Rug...

wesurviveditall

Survivor not a victim, let's beat domestic abuse together

Shrink4Men

Helping Men Break Free from Abusive Relationships Since 2009

allegra38blog

A little of everything important

L U C I D B E I N G

Ash Solomon √ Writer √ Photographer √ Historian √ Spiritualist √ Philosopher √ Film Analyst √ Leadership Guide √ Legal √

%d bloggers like this: